Heartless?: New Trump Rule Targets Poor Immigrants | The Beat With Ari Melber | MSNBC

Heartless?: New Trump Rule Targets Poor Immigrants | The Beat With Ari Melber | MSNBC


IT’S A STORY YOU MIGHT NOT HEAR ANYWHERE ELSE. ANYWHERE ELSE. I HAVE A SPECIAL REPORT TONIGHT. I HAVE A SPECIAL REPORT TONIGHT.>>>WE HAVE A STORY ON CRACKDOWN>>>WE HAVE A STORY ON CRACKDOWN ON IMMIGRANTS, EVEN LEGAL ON IMMIGRANTS, EVEN LEGAL RESIDENTS OF THE UNITED STATES. RESIDENTS OF THE UNITED STATES. THEY LAUNCHED A NEW RULE FOR THEY LAUNCHED A NEW RULE FOR PEOPLE TO PICK BETWEEN FOOD AND PEOPLE TO PICK BETWEEN FOOD AND THEIR WORKING STATUS BECAUSE THEIR WORKING STATUS BECAUSE THESE NEW RULE PUNISHES PEOPLE THESE NEW RULE PUNISHES PEOPLE WHO GET GOVERNMENT FOOD SUPPORT WHO GET GOVERNMENT FOOD SUPPORT OR HEALTH CARE WITH A TOUGHER OR HEALTH CARE WITH A TOUGHER ROAD TO LEGAL WORK. ROAD TO LEGAL WORK. LIKE A GREEN CARD OR LIKE A GREEN CARD OR CITIZENSHIP. CITIZENSHIP. SO THINK ABOUT IT LIKE THIS. SO THINK ABOUT IT LIKE THIS. UNLIKE THE BATTLES OVER PEOPLE UNLIKE THE BATTLES OVER PEOPLE WHO BROKE A LAW TO BE HERE, NOW WHO BROKE A LAW TO BE HERE, NOW WE’RE IN A PLACE WHERE LEGAL WE’RE IN A PLACE WHERE LEGAL IMMIGRANTS WHO ARE ALLOWED TO IMMIGRANTS WHO ARE ALLOWED TO USE THESE PROGRAMS ARE BASICALLY USE THESE PROGRAMS ARE BASICALLY BEING THREATENED WITH BEING THREATENED WITH PUNISHMENT. PUNISHMENT. A RULE DESIGNED TO MAKE THE PATH A RULE DESIGNED TO MAKE THE PATH TO CITIZENSHIP OR LEGAL STATUS TO CITIZENSHIP OR LEGAL STATUS HERE IN THE UNITED STATES MORE HERE IN THE UNITED STATES MORE DEPENDENT ON CLASS AND WEALTH. DEPENDENT ON CLASS AND WEALTH. IF THAT SOUNDS A LITTLE FUNNY IF THAT SOUNDS A LITTLE FUNNY LIKE, WAIT, IS THAT WHAT THIS LIKE, WAIT, IS THAT WHAT THIS WHOLE PROJECT IS ABOUT, WHOLE PROJECT IS ABOUT, OBVIOUSLY MANY CRITICS TONIGHT OBVIOUSLY MANY CRITICS TONIGHT SAYING THAT APPROACH UNDERCUTS SAYING THAT APPROACH UNDERCUTS THE LONG-STANDING TRADITION IN THE LONG-STANDING TRADITION IN THE U.S. IMMIGRATION SYSTEM, THE U.S. IMMIGRATION SYSTEM, THAT PEOPLE COME HERE FOR A THAT PEOPLE COME HERE FOR A BETTER LIFE. BETTER LIFE.>>IS THAT SENTIMENT, GIVE US>>IS THAT SENTIMENT, GIVE US YOUR TIRED, YOUR POOR, STILL YOUR TIRED, YOUR POOR, STILL OPERATIVE IN THE UNITED STATES? OPERATIVE IN THE UNITED STATES? SHOULD THOSE WORDS COME DOWN SHOULD THOSE WORDS COME DOWN FROM THE PLAQUE? FROM THE PLAQUE?>>I’M CERTAINLY NOT PREPARED TO>>I’M CERTAINLY NOT PREPARED TO TAKE ANYTHING DOWN OFF THE TAKE ANYTHING DOWN OFF THE STATUE OF LIBERTY. STATUE OF LIBERTY.>>ALRIGHTY THEN.>>ALRIGHTY THEN. NOW, THAT IS ON THE LEGAL SIDE. NOW, THAT IS ON THE LEGAL SIDE. AS FOR THE UNDOCUMENTED, TRUMP AS FOR THE UNDOCUMENTED, TRUMP OFFICIALS ARE BACK ON DEFENSE OFFICIALS ARE BACK ON DEFENSE OVER THOSE LARGE RAIDS WHICH OVER THOSE LARGE RAIDS WHICH CAME LITERALLY DAYS AFTER WHAT CAME LITERALLY DAYS AFTER WHAT WE ALL REMEMBER, WHAT WE ALL WE ALL REMEMBER, WHAT WE ALL LIVED THROUGH HERE, ONE OF THE LIVED THROUGH HERE, ONE OF THE MOST HORRIFIC ACTS OF LATINO MOST HORRIFIC ACTS OF LATINO VIOLENCE IN U.S. HISTORY. VIOLENCE IN U.S. HISTORY.>>GIVEN THE EMOTIONS OF THE>>GIVEN THE EMOTIONS OF THE COUNTRY RIGHT NOW, IN HINDSIGHT, COUNTRY RIGHT NOW, IN HINDSIGHT, DO YOU WISH THIS RAID DIDN’T DO YOU WISH THIS RAID DIDN’T HAPPEN THIS WEEK? HAPPEN THIS WEEK?>>THE TIMING WAS UNFORTUNATE.>>THE TIMING WAS UNFORTUNATE.>>UNFORTUNATE.>>UNFORTUNATE. WELL, SPEAKING OF UNFORTUNATE, WELL, SPEAKING OF UNFORTUNATE, WE NOW HAVE THE PICTURE OF WE NOW HAVE THE PICTURE OF DONALD TRUMP’S TOP BORDER DONALD TRUMP’S TOP BORDER OFFICIAL CONFRONTED WITH THIS OFFICIAL CONFRONTED WITH THIS VIDEO. VIDEO. YOU MAY HAVE SEEN IT. YOU MAY HAVE SEEN IT. WE’VE PLAYED IT MORE THAN ONCE WE’VE PLAYED IT MORE THAN ONCE HERE. HERE. A YOUNG GIRL SCARED AND UPSET AS A YOUNG GIRL SCARED AND UPSET AS SHE WAS STRANDED AND SEPARATED SHE WAS STRANDED AND SEPARATED FROM HER FATHER. FROM HER FATHER.>>IT’S NOT JUST A VICTIMLESS>>IT’S NOT JUST A VICTIMLESS CRIME THAT’S GOING ON HERE. CRIME THAT’S GOING ON HERE. FIRST OF ALL, THEY ARE HERE FIRST OF ALL, THEY ARE HERE ILLEGALLY AND IN A LOT OF TIMES ILLEGALLY AND IN A LOT OF TIMES THERE IS AN ADDITIONAL FRAUD THERE IS AN ADDITIONAL FRAUD THAT GOES WITH THIS FOR THEM TO THAT GOES WITH THIS FOR THEM TO TRY TO GET THESE JOBS IN THESE TRY TO GET THESE JOBS IN THESE COMPANIES. COMPANIES. SO I UNDERSTAND THAT THE GIRL IS SO I UNDERSTAND THAT THE GIRL IS UPSET AND I GET THAT. UPSET AND I GET THAT. BUT HER FATHER COMMITTED A BUT HER FATHER COMMITTED A CRIME. CRIME.>>REFERENCES TO CRIMES WITH>>REFERENCES TO CRIMES WITH VICTIMS USUALLY REFER TO VICTIMS USUALLY REFER TO VIOLENCE OR SOME SORT OF MAJOR VIOLENCE OR SOME SORT OF MAJOR FINANCIAL HARM. FINANCIAL HARM. HENCE THE OTHER VICTIMS. HENCE THE OTHER VICTIMS. NOT A SINGLE PERSON TAKING A NOT A SINGLE PERSON TAKING A LOW-PAYING JOB IN CONCERT WITH LOW-PAYING JOB IN CONCERT WITH AN AMERICAN COMPANY. AN AMERICAN COMPANY. NOW, THE REFERENCE THERE TO NOW, THE REFERENCE THERE TO FRAUD IS TRUE AS FAR AS IT GOES. FRAUD IS TRUE AS FAR AS IT GOES. BUT THAT, AGAIN, WOULD APPLY TO BUT THAT, AGAIN, WOULD APPLY TO THESE AMERICAN COMPANIES WHO THESE AMERICAN COMPANIES WHO ALSO FRAUDULENTLY EMPLOY THE ALSO FRAUDULENTLY EMPLOY THE UNDOCUMENTED. UNDOCUMENTED. THEY DO IT OVER AND OVER. THEY DO IT OVER AND OVER. THIS IS A MARKET ECONOMY. THIS IS A MARKET ECONOMY. THESE ARE COMPANIES WITH THESE ARE COMPANIES WITH ACCOUNTANTS AND LAWYERS AND ACCOUNTANTS AND LAWYERS AND EXECUTIVES WHO USUALLY KNOW EXECUTIVES WHO USUALLY KNOW BETTER AND WHO ARE ALSO RARELY BETTER AND WHO ARE ALSO RARELY CHARGED LET ALONE CONVICTED. CHARGED LET ALONE CONVICTED. THIS WOULD INCLUDE THE THIS WOULD INCLUDE THE PRESIDENT’S OWN COMPANY WHICH PRESIDENT’S OWN COMPANY WHICH FACES BRAND-NEW ALLEGATIONS OF FACES BRAND-NEW ALLEGATIONS OF EMPLOYING, YES, UNDOCUMENTED EMPLOYING, YES, UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS. WORKERS. THERE ARE ABOUT 8 MILLION THERE ARE ABOUT 8 MILLION UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS IN THE UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS IN THE UNITED STATES. UNITED STATES. THAT’S ABOUT 5% OF THE U.S. WORK THAT’S ABOUT 5% OF THE U.S. WORK FORCE WITH MANY COMPANIES GOING FORCE WITH MANY COMPANIES GOING BACK AND BACK AND BACK. BACK AND BACK AND BACK. TO ENGAGE IN THIS KIND OF TO ENGAGE IN THIS KIND OF COMMERCE, THIS KIND OF COMMERCE, THIS KIND OF EMPLOYMENT LAW. EMPLOYMENT LAW. NOW, IN THE LAST YEAR, I CAN NOW, IN THE LAST YEAR, I CAN TELL YOU — WE CHECKED THIS TELL YOU — WE CHECKED THIS TONIGHT — THE FEDS PROSECUTED TONIGHT — THE FEDS PROSECUTED 11 PEOPLE FOR HIRING 11 PEOPLE FOR HIRING UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS. UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS. AND THEY DIDN’T PROSECUTE ON THE AND THEY DIDN’T PROSECUTE ON THE WHOLESALE BASIS ANY ENTIRE WHOLESALE BASIS ANY ENTIRE CORPORATIONS. CORPORATIONS. THAT IS QUITE A CONTRAST. THAT IS QUITE A CONTRAST. SO KEEP THAT IN MIND AS YOU SO KEEP THAT IN MIND AS YOU WATCH TRUMP OFFICIALS WHO DON’T WATCH TRUMP OFFICIALS WHO DON’T REALLY HAVE FIRM ANSWERS TO THIS REALLY HAVE FIRM ANSWERS TO THIS LINE OF FACTUAL QUESTIONING. LINE OF FACTUAL QUESTIONING.>>IT SEEMS LIKE YOU GUYS ARE>>IT SEEMS LIKE YOU GUYS ARE TURNING A BLIND EYE TO THIS TURNING A BLIND EYE TO THIS CRIME BEING COMMITTED BY THE CRIME BEING COMMITTED BY THE PRESIDENT’S OWN COMPANIES. PRESIDENT’S OWN COMPANIES.>>I TAKE OFFENSE TO SAY ANYBODY>>I TAKE OFFENSE TO SAY ANYBODY IS TURNING A BLIND EYE TO IS TURNING A BLIND EYE TO SOMEONE THAT IS VIOLATING THE SOMEONE THAT IS VIOLATING THE LAW. LAW.>>THERE HAS NEVER BEEN A RAID.>>THERE HAS NEVER BEEN A RAID. THERE’S NEVER BEEN ANY SORT OF THERE’S NEVER BEEN ANY SORT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATION LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATION THAT WE CAN DISCERN. THAT WE CAN DISCERN.>>SO YOU REALLY CAN’T SAY THAT>>SO YOU REALLY CAN’T SAY THAT FOR SURE BECAUSE THERE ARE FOR SURE BECAUSE THERE ARE INVESTIGATIONS GOING ON ALL THE INVESTIGATIONS GOING ON ALL THE TIME THAT YOU’RE UNAWARE OF. TIME THAT YOU’RE UNAWARE OF.>>I’M JOINED BY MAR A GAY, “THE>>I’M JOINED BY MAR A GAY, “THE NEW YORK TIMES” EDITORIAL BOARD, NEW YORK TIMES” EDITORIAL BOARD, OBAMA ADMINISTRATION OFFICIAL OBAMA ADMINISTRATION OFFICIAL AND HISPANIC PHILANTHROPY I, AND HISPANIC PHILANTHROPY I, SARAH OR TEASE, SARAH OR TEASE, SARAH ORTIZ, AMERICAN RESOURCE SARAH ORTIZ, AMERICAN RESOURCE CENTER. CENTER. GOOD TO HAVE ALL OF YOU WITH US GOOD TO HAVE ALL OF YOU WITH US HERE AS EXPERTS ON THESE ISSUES. HERE AS EXPERTS ON THESE ISSUES. I WANT TO START WITH YOU, NANCY, I WANT TO START WITH YOU, NANCY, ON THAT CONTRAST. ON THAT CONTRAST. WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE TRUMP WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE TRUMP OFFICIAL’S DEFENSE THERE ARE OFFICIAL’S DEFENSE THERE ARE VERY FEW CORPORATIONS CHARGED, VERY FEW CORPORATIONS CHARGED, MAYBE THERE IS SOME SECRET MAYBE THERE IS SOME SECRET INVESTIGATION WE DON’T KNOW INVESTIGATION WE DON’T KNOW ABOUT? ABOUT?>>FLLS THE SECRET INVESTIGATION>>FLLS THE SECRET INVESTIGATION IS INCLUDING THE TRUMP IS INCLUDING THE TRUMP COMPANIES, THAT’S WHY IT’S SO COMPANIES, THAT’S WHY IT’S SO SECRET. SECRET. THE REALITY IS AT THE END OF THE THE REALITY IS AT THE END OF THE DAY IT’S THE EMPLOYER. DAY IT’S THE EMPLOYER. IT SEEMS TO BE OKAY TO GO AFTER IT SEEMS TO BE OKAY TO GO AFTER THE WORKERS IN THESE PLACES THE WORKERS IN THESE PLACES BECAUSE THEY ARE PERFORMING BECAUSE THEY ARE PERFORMING ILLEGALLY, BUT IT SEEMS NOT TO ILLEGALLY, BUT IT SEEMS NOT TO BE OKAY TO GO AFTER THE BE OKAY TO GO AFTER THE COMPANIES THEMSELVES FOR COMPANIES THEMSELVES FOR FRAUDULENT AND ILLEGAL BEHAVIOR FRAUDULENT AND ILLEGAL BEHAVIOR THEMSELVES. THEMSELVES. SO IT SEEMS TO BE, AGAIN, BACK SO IT SEEMS TO BE, AGAIN, BACK TO THE IDEA OF CLASS AND TO THE IDEA OF CLASS AND ECONOMICS BASICALLY. ECONOMICS BASICALLY. THE BIG CONCERN THAT I HAVE IN THE BIG CONCERN THAT I HAVE IN ALL OF THIS IS WE TALK ABOUT THE ALL OF THIS IS WE TALK ABOUT THE ILLEGALITY OF IT AND THE REALITY ILLEGALITY OF IT AND THE REALITY IS THAT WHEN THE RAIDS HAPPENED, IS THAT WHEN THE RAIDS HAPPENED, THEY DIDN’T HAPPEN IN PLACES THEY DIDN’T HAPPEN IN PLACES WHERE ILLEGAL ACTIVITY HAPPENS. WHERE ILLEGAL ACTIVITY HAPPENS. THEY’RE HAPPENING IN WORKPLACES. THEY’RE HAPPENING IN WORKPLACES. IT TELLS YOU SOMETHING ABOUT THE IT TELLS YOU SOMETHING ABOUT THE IMMIGRANTS THAT THEY ARE PICKING IMMIGRANTS THAT THEY ARE PICKING UP AND WHAT THEY’RE HERE FOR. UP AND WHAT THEY’RE HERE FOR. SO THAT’S THE CONCERN THAT I SO THAT’S THE CONCERN THAT I HAVE. HAVE. UNLESS THEY ARE WILLING TO GO UNLESS THEY ARE WILLING TO GO DEEP INTO THE POCKETS OF SOME OF DEEP INTO THE POCKETS OF SOME OF THE COMPANIES THAT ARE VERY MUCH THE COMPANIES THAT ARE VERY MUCH TRUMP SUPPORTERS WHICH I DOUBT TRUMP SUPPORTERS WHICH I DOUBT THEY’RE GOING TO DO, MAYBE THEY’RE GOING TO DO, MAYBE THAT’S WHY IT’S SO SEE KRELT. THAT’S WHY IT’S SO SEE KRELT. NOW 11 PROSECUTIONS DON’T TELL NOW 11 PROSECUTIONS DON’T TELL ME THEY’RE DOING REAL WORK IN ME THEY’RE DOING REAL WORK IN THAT SPACE. THAT SPACE.>>MARA, TAKE SAY LISTEN TO>>MARA, TAKE SAY LISTEN TO MR. MORGAN ON THIS SAME ISSUE. MR. MORGAN ON THIS SAME ISSUE. IT SEEMS TO BE A TROUBLE SPOT IT SEEMS TO BE A TROUBLE SPOT FOR THEM. FOR THEM.>>SURE.>>SURE.>>ARE THERE ANY CHARGES AGAINST>>ARE THERE ANY CHARGES AGAINST THE COMPANIES OR THE BUSINESS THE COMPANIES OR THE BUSINESS OWNERS? OWNERS?>>IT’S AN INVESTIGATION RIGHT>>IT’S AN INVESTIGATION RIGHT NOW. NOW.>>IN THE LAST YEAR, ZERO>>IN THE LAST YEAR, ZERO COMPANIES PROSECUTED, ONLY 11 COMPANIES PROSECUTED, ONLY 11 INDIVIDUALS PROSECUTED. INDIVIDUALS PROSECUTED. I MEAN, IF YOU FOCUSED ON THE I MEAN, IF YOU FOCUSED ON THE COMPANIES, WOULDN’T THAT HAVE COMPANIES, WOULDN’T THAT HAVE MORE OF A DETERRING EFFECT THAN MORE OF A DETERRING EFFECT THAN GOING AFTER THESE INDIVIDUALS GOING AFTER THESE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE DESPERATE? WHO ARE DESPERATE?>>SO, JAKE, AGAIN, THIS IS THE>>SO, JAKE, AGAIN, THIS IS THE THIRD TIME. THIRD TIME. THAT WAS THE INTENT OF THE THAT WAS THE INTENT OF THE INVESTIGATION — INVESTIGATION –>>I’M TALKING ABOUT IN THE LAST>>I’M TALKING ABOUT IN THE LAST YEAR, ZERO COMPANIES AND 11 YEAR, ZERO COMPANIES AND 11 INDIVIDUALS FOR THE LAST YEAR. INDIVIDUALS FOR THE LAST YEAR.>>I CAN’T SPEAK TO THE>>I CAN’T SPEAK TO THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ON HOW DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ON HOW MANY CASES THEY HAVE. MANY CASES THEY HAVE.>>YEA, I THINK IT’S A LITTLE>>YEA, I THINK IT’S A LITTLE BIT PAINFUL FOR ME TO TALK ABOUT BIT PAINFUL FOR ME TO TALK ABOUT POLICY HERE BECAUSE I THINK THIS POLICY HERE BECAUSE I THINK THIS IS ABOUT POLITICS. IS ABOUT POLITICS. AND IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT — AND IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT — THESE ARE NOT POLICIES BEING THESE ARE NOT POLICIES BEING DRIVEN BY REAS. DRIVEN BY REAS. THEY’RE BEING DRIVEN, I BELIEVE, THEY’RE BEING DRIVEN, I BELIEVE, BY THE NEED AND DESIRE TO THROW BY THE NEED AND DESIRE TO THROW RED MEAT TO DONALD TRUMP’S BASE RED MEAT TO DONALD TRUMP’S BASE WHO UNFORTUNATELY — IT’S LIKE WHO UNFORTUNATELY — IT’S LIKE THEY FORGOT WHAT THEIR MOTHER THEY FORGOT WHAT THEIR MOTHER TAUGHT THEM AND THEY ARE TAUGHT THEM AND THEY ARE RESPONDING TO HATRED AGAINST RESPONDING TO HATRED AGAINST BLACK AND BROWN PEOPLE. BLACK AND BROWN PEOPLE. AND I THINK WE HAVE A LONG AND I THINK WE HAVE A LONG HISTORY IN THIS COUNTRY OF HISTORY IN THIS COUNTRY OF CRIMINALIZING AFRICAN AMERICANS CRIMINALIZING AFRICAN AMERICANS AND LATINO PEOPLE. AND LATINO PEOPLE. AND I THINK THAT THAT’S WHAT THE AND I THINK THAT THAT’S WHAT THE ADMINISTRATION IS PLAYING UPON. ADMINISTRATION IS PLAYING UPON. AND IT’S REALLY — IT’S SAD. AND IT’S REALLY — IT’S SAD. I’M EMBARRASSED AS AN AMERICAN. I’M EMBARRASSED AS AN AMERICAN. AND, YOU KNOW, THERE IS A REAL AND, YOU KNOW, THERE IS A REAL CONVERSATION TO HAVE, CONVERSATION TO HAVE, ABSOLUTELY, ABOUT POLICIES AT ABSOLUTELY, ABOUT POLICIES AT THE BORDER. THE BORDER. AND I THINK THE DEMOCRATS AND I THINK THE DEMOCRATS ACTUALLY ALLOW THE TRUMP ACTUALLY ALLOW THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION FAR TOO MUCH ADMINISTRATION FAR TOO MUCH SPACE TO OPERATE ON HATE AND SPACE TO OPERATE ON HATE AND FEAR WHEN THEY DON’T OFFER AN FEAR WHEN THEY DON’T OFFER AN ALTERNATIVE VISION FOR THE ALTERNATIVE VISION FOR THE COUNTRY THAT IS COMPREHENSIVE. COUNTRY THAT IS COMPREHENSIVE. AND SO IF THEY ARE NOT TELLING AND SO IF THEY ARE NOT TELLING THE STORY TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE THE STORY TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ABOUT HOW WE CAN HAVE SAFE, ABOUT HOW WE CAN HAVE SAFE, SECURE AND FAIR BORDERS HUMANELY SECURE AND FAIR BORDERS HUMANELY AND WITH RESPECT AND HUMAN AND WITH RESPECT AND HUMAN DIGNITY, THEN THEY ARE ALLOWING DIGNITY, THEN THEY ARE ALLOWING DONALD TRUMP TO FILL THAT VOID DONALD TRUMP TO FILL THAT VOID WITH HATE MONGERING AND FEAR WITH HATE MONGERING AND FEAR MONGERING AT A TIME WHEN HATE MONGERING AT A TIME WHEN HATE CRIMES ARE ON THE RISE AND AN CRIMES ARE ON THE RISE AND AN ELECTION IS ON THE HORIZON. ELECTION IS ON THE HORIZON. AND I THINK PEOPLE REALLY NEED AND I THINK PEOPLE REALLY NEED TO START TALKING ABOUT HUMAN TO START TALKING ABOUT HUMAN RIGHTS AND HUMAN DIGNITY AND RIGHTS AND HUMAN DIGNITY AND WHERE THAT FITS INTO THIS WHERE THAT FITS INTO THIS CONVERSATION. CONVERSATION.>>LUCERO, HOW ABOUT YOU?>>LUCERO, HOW ABOUT YOU?>>YES, I THINK ONE THING THAT’S>>YES, I THINK ONE THING THAT’S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER IS THE IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER IS THE IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY HAS BEEN IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY HAS BEEN RECRUITED SO VERY DANGEROUS RECRUITED SO VERY DANGEROUS SECTORS LIKE THE CONSTRUCTION SECTORS LIKE THE CONSTRUCTION SECTOR AND THE POULTRY INDUSTRY SECTOR AND THE POULTRY INDUSTRY WHERE JOBS — THEY’RE OFTEN WHERE JOBS — THEY’RE OFTEN EXPLOITED AND JOBS ARE VERY EXPLOITED AND JOBS ARE VERY DANGEROUS. DANGEROUS. THIS IS NOT BY ACCIDENT. THIS IS NOT BY ACCIDENT. THIS IS VERY INTENTIONAL. THIS IS VERY INTENTIONAL. AND ONE THING THAT’S IMPORTANT AND ONE THING THAT’S IMPORTANT TO REALLY TAKE INTO ACCOUNT IN TO REALLY TAKE INTO ACCOUNT IN MISSISSIPPI IN PARTICULAR AND MISSISSIPPI IN PARTICULAR AND LOUISIANA, CENTRAL AMERICAN LOUISIANA, CENTRAL AMERICAN COMMUNITIES AND ASIAN IMMIGRANTS COMMUNITIES AND ASIAN IMMIGRANTS REBUILT THOSE AREAS AFTER REBUILT THOSE AREAS AFTER KATRINA. KATRINA. AND AGAIN, THERE WAS A VERY AND AGAIN, THERE WAS A VERY SPECIFIC RECRUITMENT OF SPECIFIC RECRUITMENT OF IMMIGRANTS WHERE EMPLOYERS, MANY IMMIGRANTS WHERE EMPLOYERS, MANY WERE ABLE TO EMPLOY THESE WERE ABLE TO EMPLOY THESE INDIVIDUALS AND ARE NOT BEING INDIVIDUALS AND ARE NOT BEING PROSECUTED. PROSECUTED. SO, AGAIN, IT REALLY IS ABOUT SO, AGAIN, IT REALLY IS ABOUT ACCOUNTABILITY AND IT IS ABOUT ACCOUNTABILITY AND IT IS ABOUT OUR ECONOMY AS A WHOLE THAT OUR ECONOMY AS A WHOLE THAT BENEFITS ON THE BACKS OF THESE BENEFITS ON THE BACKS OF THESE INDIVIDUALS. INDIVIDUALS. UNFORTUNATELY, THE ONLY ONES UNFORTUNATELY, THE ONLY ONES THAT CARRY THE BURDEN ARE THE THAT CARRY THE BURDEN ARE THE IMMIGRANTS. IMMIGRANTS. AND AT THIS TIME IT IS REALLY AND AT THIS TIME IT IS REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WE REALLY LOOK AT IMPORTANT THAT WE REALLY LOOK AT ALL OF THE INCIDENTS THAT HAVE ALL OF THE INCIDENTS THAT HAVE HAPPENED IN THE LAST WEEK IN A HAPPENED IN THE LAST WEEK IN A MUCH MORE HISTORICAL LENS. MUCH MORE HISTORICAL LENS. FOR THE PAST 30 YEARS, WE HAVE FOR THE PAST 30 YEARS, WE HAVE NOT HAD COMPREHENSIVE NOT HAD COMPREHENSIVE IMMIGRATION REFORM. IMMIGRATION REFORM. SINCE 1986, WE’VE SEEN THE SINCE 1986, WE’VE SEEN THE NUMBER OF UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS NUMBER OF UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS GROW AND THE EXPLOITATION AND GROW AND THE EXPLOITATION AND FEAR IN THESE COMMUNITIES GROW FEAR IN THESE COMMUNITIES GROW AS WELL. AS WELL. AND SO YOU SEE THAT THE LATINO AND SO YOU SEE THAT THE LATINO COMMUNITY IS OFTEN VILIFIED AND COMMUNITY IS OFTEN VILIFIED AND SCAPEGOATED IN THIS ARENA AND, SCAPEGOATED IN THIS ARENA AND, AGAIN, THROUGH THIS HISTORICAL AGAIN, THROUGH THIS HISTORICAL LENS. LENS. SO WHEN WE’RE SEEING THESE SO WHEN WE’RE SEEING THESE ATTACKS, THE RAIDS IN ATTACKS, THE RAIDS IN MISSISSIPPI, THE SHOOLTINGS IN E MISSISSIPPI, THE SHOOLTINGS IN E PASO, THESE ALL HAVE A THOROUGH PASO, THESE ALL HAVE A THOROUGH LENS WE NEED TO LOOK AT THEM LENS WE NEED TO LOOK AT THEM THROUGH BECAUSE, AGAIN, THIS IS THROUGH BECAUSE, AGAIN, THIS IS INACTION BY CONGRESS OVER 30 INACTION BY CONGRESS OVER 30 YEARS. YEARS. AND NOW WE HAVE REALLY THE SPARK AND NOW WE HAVE REALLY THE SPARK IN THE PRAIRIE FIRE, WHICH IS IN THE PRAIRIE FIRE, WHICH IS THIS PRESIDENT WHO IS STOKING THIS PRESIDENT WHO IS STOKING THE FLAMES OF HATRED AND REALLY THE FLAMES OF HATRED AND REALLY ANTI-IMMIGRANT SENTIMENT THAT ANTI-IMMIGRANT SENTIMENT THAT HAS LED TO WHAT WE’VE SEEN OVER HAS LED TO WHAT WE’VE SEEN OVER THE LAST WEEK. THE LAST WEEK.>>AND WHAT DO YOU SAY TO PEOPLE>>AND WHAT DO YOU SAY TO PEOPLE WHO HEAR ABOUT THIS OR HEAR WHO HEAR ABOUT THIS OR HEAR ABOUT IT AT A DISTANCE AND SAY, ABOUT IT AT A DISTANCE AND SAY, OKAY, WELL, A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE OKAY, WELL, A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE SUFFERING, A LOT OF POOR PEOPLE SUFFERING, A LOT OF POOR PEOPLE ARE IN AMERICA. ARE IN AMERICA. A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE BORN HERE A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE BORN HERE AND HAVE VERY LITTLE ACCESS TO AND HAVE VERY LITTLE ACCESS TO ANYTHING AND THEY SAY WHY SHOULD ANYTHING AND THEY SAY WHY SHOULD THOSE PUBLIC BENEFITS BE GOING THOSE PUBLIC BENEFITS BE GOING TO PEOPLE WHO COME HERE. TO PEOPLE WHO COME HERE.>>ONE THING THAT’S IMPORTANT IS>>ONE THING THAT’S IMPORTANT IS IT WAS ONE OF 200,000 IT WAS ONE OF 200,000 INDIVIDUALS WHO SUBMITTED PUBLIC INDIVIDUALS WHO SUBMITTED PUBLIC COMMENTS TO THE CHARGE. COMMENTS TO THE CHARGE. ONE THING THAT IS IMPORTANT IS ONE THING THAT IS IMPORTANT IS IMMIGRANTS ARE THE ECONOMIC IMMIGRANTS ARE THE ECONOMIC ENGINE OF THIS COUNTRY IN MANY ENGINE OF THIS COUNTRY IN MANY WAYS AND HAVE BEEN PRODUCING WAYS AND HAVE BEEN PRODUCING ECONOMICALLY FOR GENERATIONS. ECONOMICALLY FOR GENERATIONS. AND SO IT IS — IT’S LOPSIDED TO AND SO IT IS — IT’S LOPSIDED TO SAY THAT IMMIGRANTS ARE NOT SAY THAT IMMIGRANTS ARE NOT CONTRIBUTING TO THE ECONOMY. CONTRIBUTING TO THE ECONOMY. FURTHERMORE, IMMIGRANTS, AS THE FURTHERMORE, IMMIGRANTS, AS THE FINAL RULE SUGGESTS, IMMIGRANTS FINAL RULE SUGGESTS, IMMIGRANTS ARE NOT USING PUBLIC BENEFITS. ARE NOT USING PUBLIC BENEFITS. OFTENTIMES THEY ARE NOT ELIGIBLE OFTENTIMES THEY ARE NOT ELIGIBLE FOR THOSE BENEFITS, AND SO, FOR THOSE BENEFITS, AND SO, AGAIN, THIS COME PAIN AND THIS AGAIN, THIS COME PAIN AND THIS FINAL RULE IS REALLY ABOUT FINAL RULE IS REALLY ABOUT STOKING FEAR AND REALLY CREATING STOKING FEAR AND REALLY CREATING THIS OTHERNESS AND FEAR OF THE THIS OTHERNESS AND FEAR OF THE OTHER SO THAT VOTERS AND OTHER OTHER SO THAT VOTERS AND OTHER INDIVIDUALS WHO MAY NOT HAVE INDIVIDUALS WHO MAY NOT HAVE ENOUGH INFORMATION OR WHO ARE ENOUGH INFORMATION OR WHO ARE REALLY GOING TO LOOK AT THE REALLY GOING TO LOOK AT THE POLITICS AS OPPOSED TO THE POLITICS AS OPPOSED TO THE POLICY ISSUES WILL LOOK TO THEIR POLICY ISSUES WILL LOOK TO THEIR IMMIGRANT NEIGHBORS AND THEIR IMMIGRANT NEIGHBORS AND THEIR IMMIGRANT BROTHERS AND SISTERS IMMIGRANT BROTHERS AND SISTERS AS THE OTHER, AS COMPETITION IN AS THE OTHER, AS COMPETITION IN AN ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT WHEN, AN ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT WHEN, AGAIN, THESE INDIVIDUALS ARE AGAIN, THESE INDIVIDUALS ARE WORKING IN INDUSTRIES THAT ARE WORKING IN INDUSTRIES THAT ARE DANGEROUS, THAT ARE OFTEN UNDER DANGEROUS, THAT ARE OFTEN UNDER PAID AND DO NEED TO BE PAID AND DO NEED TO BE REGULATED. REGULATED. AND, AGAIN, BEING IMMIGRANTS IN AND, AGAIN, BEING IMMIGRANTS IN THE UNITED STATES DOES NOT ALLOW THE UNITED STATES DOES NOT ALLOW THEM TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF ANY OF THEM TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF ANY OF THESE PUBLIC BENEFITS. THESE PUBLIC BENEFITS.>>LUCERO ORTIZ, THANK YOU SO>>LUCERO ORTIZ, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US. MUCH FOR JOINING US. I TURN BACK TO THE PANEL IN NEW I TURN BACK TO THE PANEL IN NEW YORK. YORK. I WONDER IF WE CAN BUILD ON THAT I WONDER IF WE CAN BUILD ON THAT CONVERSATION BECAUSE I DO THINK CONVERSATION BECAUSE I DO THINK THERE IS A MISUNDERSTANDING. THERE IS A MISUNDERSTANDING. IT SEEMS IF YOU ARE HERE IT SEEMS IF YOU ARE HERE LEGALLY, THERE IS A LEGAL OR LEGALLY, THERE IS A LEGAL OR ILLEGAL LINE UNDOCUMENTED. ILLEGAL LINE UNDOCUMENTED.>>THAT’S RIGHT.>>THAT’S RIGHT.>>IF YOU’RE HERE LEGALLY, IN>>IF YOU’RE HERE LEGALLY, IN THEORY, WE WANT THE WHOLE THING THEORY, WE WANT THE WHOLE THING TO WORK TOGETHER. TO WORK TOGETHER. IF YOU START GOING DOWN THE ROAD IF YOU START GOING DOWN THE ROAD OF HAVING A BLATANTLY OF HAVING A BLATANTLY TWO-TIERED, TWO-CLASS SYSTEM, TWO-TIERED, TWO-CLASS SYSTEM, THIS WAS A STEPHEN MILLER IDEA THIS WAS A STEPHEN MILLER IDEA THAT SAYS, WE’RE GOING TO LET THAT SAYS, WE’RE GOING TO LET PEOPLE IN. PEOPLE IN. THEY ARE HERE LEGALLY. THEY ARE HERE LEGALLY. WHATEVER THEIR RACE — PANELISTS WHATEVER THEIR RACE — PANELISTS ARE RIGHT TO SAY MUCH OF THIS ARE RIGHT TO SAY MUCH OF THIS TARGETS LATINOS. TARGETS LATINOS. BUT WHATEVER IT IS, OH, NOW, BUT WHATEVER IT IS, OH, NOW, OKAY, YOU CAN BE HERE, BUT YOU OKAY, YOU CAN BE HERE, BUT YOU HAVE TO BE HIGHER CLASS TO STAY HAVE TO BE HIGHER CLASS TO STAY OR WE’RE GOING TO PUNISH YOU OR WE’RE GOING TO PUNISH YOU OTHERWISE. OTHERWISE. YOU’RE REALLY GOING BACK TO YOU’RE REALLY GOING BACK TO SOMETHING WE HAVEN’T SEEN AT SOMETHING WE HAVEN’T SEEN AT LEAST SINCE THE ’65 IMMIGRATION LEAST SINCE THE ’65 IMMIGRATION ACT UNDER WRITTEN LAW WHICH IS A ACT UNDER WRITTEN LAW WHICH IS A TWO-TIER SYSTEM. TWO-TIER SYSTEM.>>IT’S STILL ABOUT CLASSISM.>>IT’S STILL ABOUT CLASSISM. THIS IS STILL ABOUT HOW WE KNOW THIS IS STILL ABOUT HOW WE KNOW THE FOLKS THAT ARE COMING THE FOLKS THAT ARE COMING THROUGH, THAT ARE IMMIGRANTS THROUGH, THAT ARE IMMIGRANTS THAT DON’T NEED BENEFITS AND THAT DON’T NEED BENEFITS AND THEY’RE HERE LEGALLY LOOK A THEY’RE HERE LEGALLY LOOK A CERTAIN WAY. CERTAIN WAY. LET’S BE CLEAR ABOUT WHAT THAT LET’S BE CLEAR ABOUT WHAT THAT IS. IS.>>RIGHT.>>RIGHT.>>AND SO THIS IS YET ANOTHER>>AND SO THIS IS YET ANOTHER WAY — THEY WERE LOSING THE WAY — THEY WERE LOSING THE ARGUMENT ABOUT ILLEGAL ARGUMENT ABOUT ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS, AND THEY KNEW THEY IMMIGRANTS, AND THEY KNEW THEY WERE LOSING IT. WERE LOSING IT. MOST OF AMERICANS FEAR THAT IF MOST OF AMERICANS FEAR THAT IF CLOSING THE DOORS TO A PATH TO CLOSING THE DOORS TO A PATH TO LEGAL IMMIGRATION FOR FOLKS IS A LEGAL IMMIGRATION FOR FOLKS IS A MISTAKE. MISTAKE. SO MORE AND MORE OF THE AMERICAN SO MORE AND MORE OF THE AMERICAN PUBLIC WAS LOOKING FOR THAT PUBLIC WAS LOOKING FOR THAT OPPORTUNITY TO A PATH TOWARDS OPPORTUNITY TO A PATH TOWARDS IMMIGRATION REFORM. IMMIGRATION REFORM. AS THEY START TO LOSE THAT AS THEY START TO LOSE THAT BATTLE, THEY NEED TO FIND BATTLE, THEY NEED TO FIND SOMETHING ELSE TO KIND OF STOKE SOMETHING ELSE TO KIND OF STOKE THE FLAMES. THE FLAMES.>>RIGHT.>>RIGHT.>>AND THIS IS IT.>>AND THIS IS IT. NOW IT’S LIKE, YOU’RE NOT GOING NOW IT’S LIKE, YOU’RE NOT GOING TO GET PUBLIC BENEFITS, BUT THEY TO GET PUBLIC BENEFITS, BUT THEY DON’T ASK FOR THEM. DON’T ASK FOR THEM.>>AND BEFORE WE GO, MARA, THERE>>AND BEFORE WE GO, MARA, THERE ARE REPORTS IN THE WASHINGTON ARE REPORTS IN THE WASHINGTON POST THAT THE PRESIDENT IS UPSET POST THAT THE PRESIDENT IS UPSET ABOUT ASPECTS OF WHAT’S BEEN ABOUT ASPECTS OF WHAT’S BEEN HAPPENING. HAPPENING. NAJEELY, NAJEELY, NAMELY HE DOESN’T LIKE IT WHEN NAMELY HE DOESN’T LIKE IT WHEN PEOPLE CALL HIM RACIST. PEOPLE CALL HIM RACIST. HE SAYS HE’S A BRANDING — HE HE SAYS HE’S A BRANDING — HE RECOILS FROM BEING CALLED THE R RECOILS FROM BEING CALLED THE R WORD EVEN THOUGH SOME OF HIS WORD EVEN THOUGH SOME OF HIS ACTIONS AND WORDS HAVE BEEN, ACTIONS AND WORDS HAVE BEEN, QUOTE, PLAINLY RACIST. QUOTE, PLAINLY RACIST.>>WELL, A RACIST IS AS A RACIST>>WELL, A RACIST IS AS A RACIST DOES. DOES. I MEAN, I DON’T KNOW HOW ELSE TO I MEAN, I DON’T KNOW HOW ELSE TO SAY IT. SAY IT. HE HAS ROUTINELY DEPLOYED RACIST HE HAS ROUTINELY DEPLOYED RACIST LANGUAGE, RACIST PRACTICES SINCE LANGUAGE, RACIST PRACTICES SINCE LONG BEFORE HE WAS PRESIDENT OF LONG BEFORE HE WAS PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES. THE UNITED STATES. HE SEEMS MORE CONCERNED ABOUT HE SEEMS MORE CONCERNED ABOUT BEING CALLED SOMETHING THAT IS BEING CALLED SOMETHING THAT IS OFFENSIVE BUT IS ACCURATE THAN OFFENSIVE BUT IS ACCURATE THAN HE DOES ABOUT ACTUALLY DOING HE DOES ABOUT ACTUALLY DOING SOMETHING ABOUT RACISM. SOMETHING ABOUT RACISM. SO I WOULD, I WOULD — IF I WERE SO I WOULD, I WOULD — IF I WERE SITTING HERE IN FRONT OF HIM, I SITTING HERE IN FRONT OF HIM, I WOULD SUGGEST THAT HE, YOU KNOW, WOULD SUGGEST THAT HE, YOU KNOW, TAKE A LONG, HARD LOOK IN THE TAKE A LONG, HARD LOOK IN THE MIRROR — MIRROR –>>I’VE GOT TO GO, BUT I WILL>>I’VE GOT TO GO, BUT I WILL JUST ADD THAT WHILE THE JUST ADD THAT WHILE THE STANDARDS ARE LOW THESE DAYS, STANDARDS ARE LOW THESE DAYS, TREATING A FUNDAMENTAL MORAL TREATING A FUNDAMENTAL MORAL CRISIS IS A BRANDING CRISIS.

100 thoughts to “Heartless?: New Trump Rule Targets Poor Immigrants | The Beat With Ari Melber | MSNBC”

  1. US has 5% of it's workforce as undocumented, so from now on since Trump doesn't want to count illegal immigrants in census data, let's add that 5% to the unemployment numbers since those jobs are criminally filled. we now have an 8% unemployment rate good job Trump!

  2. so now he's targeting "Legal" immigrants….well if that don't tell you "Spankinstein" is raciest than you probably deserve him

  3. So I guess it is now inhumane for Law Enforcement to arrest anyone in front of their children because they will be separated. I guess Liberals must want everyone out of Jail who is separated from their children…..nice. Here is some sound advice STOP using children to garner the sympathy vote to enact lawlessness!

  4. Idiots. This mandate has been on the books for over 140 years. Obama deported ten times as many immigrants. Over 300 million people were murdered under communism in Russia, and you idiots want it here too.. There are Russian Politicians here on YouTube, letting you know, you are known as "useful idiots". And were the first ones lined up and shot after they did their job advocating for gun confiscation. Those who refuse to learn history are doomed to repeat it. Only idiots and racists think Trump is a racist.

  5. Its not a victimless crime. The victim is Stephen Miller, who really hates immigrants and doesn't want to live in a country with so many of them.

  6. In short, the Trump campaign sees in the white supremacist label a potentially useful rallying point, as Hillary Clinton’s “basket of deplorables” was in 2016. “They’re trying to make the case that anyone who supports this president is a racist,” CNN, MSNBC say 'racist' more than 1,100 times regarding Trump 'go …

    https://thehill.com/homenews/media/453300-cnn-msnbc-say-racist-636-times-regarding-trump-go-back-tweet-since-sunday Jul 16, 2019 – CNN and MSNBC have said the word "racist" more than 1100 times since … and Trump's remarks have been called out as racist by much of the …

  7. I heard a person complaining how they had to pay 25$/hr to get people to work for them because of low unemployment … Why do Dems call for a government imposed minimum wage? They also complain that people are not seeing a growth in income…DUH! If there were not enough CITIZENS available to do the job at "X" wage then the companies would automatically have to pay more to stay in business and attract new employees …they do not have to do that if they can simply import more low skilled workers ..automation is already doing a great job of killing off low skilled jobs

  8. The underdogs are my lions
    The silent ones are my choir
    The women will be my soldiers
    With the weight of life on their shoulders
    The sea waves are my evening gown
    And the sun on my head is my crown
    I made this queendom on my own
    And all the mountains are my throne
    I hunt the grounds for empathy
    And hate the way it hides from me
    Of care and thirst I have become
    You have a home in my queendom
    Aurora

  9. The excuse for what they're doing, the explanation, the thing they are saying takes all responsibility and free will out of their hands is the simple fact that "they committed a CRIME". Um, this guy ttump, he committed a CRIME or two. How many crimes must a president commit and where is the line drawn between crimes for which they won't indict a sitting president and crimes so egregious they must break that rule and arrest one?

  10. Trump wants LEGAL immigrants, who have someone who sponsors them, and can provide for them selves after arrive and become citizens. And not be be on welfare for who knows how long ?

  11. Did they raid Trump's companies? I bet they didn't!! Did they punish the company owners? I bet they didn't!!! Cause they have an excuse, right??? Hypocrites, they're typical hypocrites, and Trump's the biggest he makes me sick…

  12. Trump hurts little children without blinking an eye. He's a racist sak of sht. Big Blue Wave coming to clean this stain away.

  13. Well look what the government to native american indians took their children away and put them in boarding schools my mom said they were punshed if they spoke their own language they were made to kneel for hours and when they got tired and tried to sit down they would get hit on the hands by the matrin just be glad that these children dont have to go thru that

  14. what crime?he was working to support his family,not out stealing,killing all the things trump wants us to believe they are doing,its trump and his followers who are the dangerous criminals.the government has gone crazy,take the trumps money away,see what they do to survive,it will be illegal immoral and dishonest,oh wait,thats the way theyve always done.

  15. Trump, his policies, and his supporters disgust me to the core. This country was built on the blood and sweat of immigrants. Trump and his racist, ignorant followers are too stupid to understand that fact. My family came to America ten years before the Mayflower did; and millions of aboriginals (like the native Mexican peoples) were in what is now the United States thousands of years before that. We are the invaders and Trump is just a racist pig using the Mexicans as a scapegoat to distract from his own corruption (which is pretty much the playbook of every fascist leader for the past century).

  16. So since Trump's new policy wants to deport LEGAL immigrants who fall below the poverty line, and technically all non-Native American Caucasians are essentially just 'legal immigrants', I guess we should start seeing ICE raids on trailer parks deporting all the underprivileged white trash to wherever their forefathers came from…

  17. Lies….Thank you MSNBC for showing your bias….what Trump said has nothing to do with legal immigrants…or children or people seeking asylum. He is targeting people who have live in this country illegally for years and years. The Law is the Law. ICE are leaving children crying because their parents didn't follow the law and come into this county legally.

  18. If they can't afford to live in the USA they should go back to their original country. Why should we be stuck paying for them? If they refuse to return to their country, we should publicly execute them. Hanging would be good. Thank you Donald Trump for standing up for US citizens.

  19. What is the difference between the Nazis and ICE? That the ICE photos of children in cages are in color.
    This is what USA is today, a Racist Nation!
    This Christian Nation supports Torture of Children, just like ISIS!

  20. It's kind of obvious that trump is taking control of law and order. he is trying to prosecute none trump supporters,and trump supporters will get away with anything. You people will start to get it soon. Remember what they did in the rose garden not so long ago. He has got all the right wing media poparganda channels saying the same song. It's crazy but it is what I see that they are trying to do. If you are Latino and you support trump you are ok if you are black and Brown and support trump you are ok America is to easily brainwashed.

  21. ICE DID THEIR JOB. HOW CAN YOU TELL THEM NOT TO DO THEIR JOB. THAT'S WHAT THEY GET PAID FOR. WHO DOES NOT WANT THEM TO EARN THEIR CHECK. THEY ARE THE LAW FOR AMERICA. WHY DONT YOU GUYS GO TO THOSE URBAN SCHOOLS AND HELP THOSE POOR LITTLE CHILDREN BECAUSE THERE IS NO FOOD IN THEIR HOUSES.

    HOW ABOUT THEY ARE WALKING IN THE COLD WITH NO COAT. I KNOW BECAUSE I WORKED AT A SCHOOL NINE YEARS WITH CRYING DEPRIVED KIDS EVERYDAY. HOW MANY KIDS GOT SHOES, UNIFORMS, COATS AND FOOD. WE DONF NEED ALL OF THOSS PEOPLE YOU GUYS TRYING TO BRING IN. THEY SHOULDN'T BE HERE TAKING STUFF FROM AMERICA. THEY BROKE IN TO GET WHAT THEY WANT.

    DONT BE SHOWING US CRYING CHILDREN ITS THE LAW TO ARREST THEIR PARENTS. TAKE THE CHILDREN HOME IF YOU DON'T WANT TO SEE THEM CRY. THATS AN EXCUSE TO KEEP FLOODING THIS COUNTRY EATING UP AMERICAN U.S. CITIZE3N WEALTH.

    I FEEL SORRY FOF CHILDREN IN A STRANGE LAND WITH DISOBEDIENT PARENTS WHO WONT OBEY THE LAW. GIVE THEIR CHILDREN TO THEIR GOVERNMENTS AND SEND THE PARENTS HOME. YOU BRINGING TO BIG IF A BURDEN IN AMERICANS WITH THEM WE OWE THEM NOTHING. THATS OUR STUFF. WONT YOU HELP THE POOR BLACK MAN COM'E OUT HIS MESS, SEND HIM TO REHABILITATION AND SCHOOL SO HE CAN BE GREAT. IS THEIR A BIASED ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE BLACKS VERSUS ILLEGALS.

    I DONT CARE WHAT THE STATUE OF LIBERTY SAYS WE DONT OWE NOBODY ANYTHING. OUR ANCESTORS BULIT THESE BUILDINGS AND PICKED COTTON IN THE HEAT . FOR WHAT . SO YOU GUYS CAN KEEP. BRINGING DISOBEDIENT REBELLION HERE AND MAKING A WAY FOR THEM TO CATERED TO. WE DONT HAVE TO CHANGE NOTHING FOR THEM,
    .

    .

  22. Its hypacritical that the border chief emphasizes the fact that the little girl's father committed a crime but is not holding this so-called president accountable for committing multiple crimes as laid out in the Mueller report as well as violations to the emoluments clause and regulations of federal officials regarding nepotism. Where is his dedication to the law and his perjury of taking the oath of president while having violated the constitution before and while and then after taking that oath to uphold the very Constitution upon which his oath rests? Seems more illegal than a man trying to take care of his family by going to work instead of actively colluding with Russia to win an election and bleed a nation dry of any sense of morality. Impeach this so-called president.

  23. This is nothing new. It's been around forever. We are just enforcing an old rule. It's time to start obeying the rules and the laws.

  24. Trump uses his white privileges that he's allowed to break the law. It's just any one of color is not allowed special treatment of any sort.

  25. Heartless is an understatement. This piece of crap (Trump) has never done a single humanitarian thing in his life. If he can take his racist and white supremacy rhetoric to his rallies and stir up unrest among his like minded followers he is in his element and as happy as his heart desires. His wife and her family are also immigrants but because they are white they don't fall into his category of undesirables which of course is anybody that isn't white.

  26. Sorry little girl your parents knew the consequence for breaking the law so blame your parents for not doing the right thing and coming here legal.

  27. This should get tossed in court.Trump is essentially trying to rewrite immigration law which is the purview of Congress.

  28. ""WHY ARE POS COPS AND POS TRUMP SO AFRAID OF A CAMERA , BECAUSE THE CAMERA DON'T LIE AND THEY DO …….FDT…… FTP""" NO IQ NEEDED TO BE A POS COPS , ALWAYS FISHING TO ARREST AND ABUSE…….

  29. But her Father committed a crime / J.C Please STOP! this BS, the only crime here is the fake and phony charges placed against her father putting him in some bs cell separating her from her father. The criminal act was committed by the company or corporations when they put the undocumented immigrants on THEIR PAYROLL, watching out for the little guy while cheating Americans out of a job. Who is the real criminal here. Why are these business not held accountable for hiring undocumented immigrants? Why aren't corporations held accountable for hiring undocumented immigrants? Why shouldn't Trump not be held accountable for the very same crime? He that pushes hardest is the most guiltiest. There should be a very large fines placed against any business including the I'm above the law corporations and Trump, the money should be placed in the State unemployment fund. Trump making up new rules who has hired many undocumented immigrants

    Please Congress Impeach Trump. The Mueller report.

  30. Do undocumented immigrants have a right to due process?
    Yes. Courts have consistently held that anyone on United States soil is protected by the Constitution’s right to due process, even if they illegally entered the country, though people generally have greater legal protections inside the country than at the border.://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/25/us/politics/due-process-undocumented-immigrants.html

  31. Words are indeed very powerful and do indeed mean something. Human beings all too often MIS-USE words. As an example: there really is only one r ace, the human race. We are not different races or species. Human beings are human beings. Illegal immigrants are human beings. They are not (illegal) aliens as in UFO, science fiction like, outer space, aliens. Human beings are not trash, so terms like "white trash"… is wrong to use.

  32. Wait a minute didn't immigrants people that are here from there ancestors, once their ancestors came here they lead the way to and open door for them all to be here today. the native Americans open arms and didn't tell them they had to leave, don't forget they just killed them. This is the same thing 😂 they have always done. They are taking something from whites tell me what are they taking,you can't take anything that u never had. Guess what we all are living on land that don't belong to any of us. This is the con job that they play on people

  33. been here over a year with the gov paying for your life and still cant afford to live on your own? sounds fair to me. I wish europe offered that plan, Come here free, live free, eat free, free medical but get a job and live on your own in a year or you go to the back of the line. thats the sweetest deal in the entire world. No country offers anything like that. well, one does. US!

  34. Trump would rather bring H1B visa tech workers from overseas to take high paying tech jobs away from American citizens. I would rather Trump cap the number of H1B visas.

  35. It's Time for change it is time for the American people the masses to fight back against this modern day 21st century Tyrann and the Tyrannical acts from our government and the corrupted corporationsn ( monopolies). This may be a disappointing reality to most. Here are the facts mainstream media these corporations ( monopolies) are part of the corruption there are 4 major mainstream media corporations that work for our courrpt government this is the elite 2% of the population writes the legislation the legislative branch panders to there people and pass law's for a few out of 300mil . nothing will get fixed until we eradicate the corruption in our politics and get rid of the corrupted politicians that's destroying and robbing the masses Fake News is a reality stop watching cable television let eradicate the Congress Senators, Governors and any elected officials and replace them with real people the masses the people who who are not part of the highest scum of society once that is fixed We can tackle our major issues in this country but only if we cand get the corruption out of politics and that dirty money and more than i got time to point out right bow

  36. One crime you neglected was the identity theft. This does cause insurance, health care, and employement income fraud on an innocent US citizen. As someone attacked by identtity theft this is not a minor crime.

  37. orange turd is trying to make USA a private club – with the same fate as his casinos – we will be morally bankrupt and soon financially too!

  38. The average American won't stoop to do the jobs that immigrants will do. Fruit is rotting on trees because of Trump's policies. Even people with legal documents are being targeted. These workers pay tax and that helps the country.

  39. So let's get this straight. The most racist people live in the South, (duh), who are also the same people who brought millions of blacks to the U.S. Why? Free labor so they could get rich. The robber barons who built the Transcontinental Railroad (Crocker) brought the Chinese to the U.S. Why, he needed free (cheap) labor so that he could get rich. What should we learn from this? The rich are basically racist but they always ignore their racism if they need cheap labor to get richer. In today's world, the only workers the rich need, are foreign computer programmers, hence we are now hearing economic reasons for stopping even LEGAL immigration.

  40. nobody real believes what you are saying……..you are all just opinion and spin….showing a crying little girl can you say that had any other purpose than to try and use her for your opinion position?

  41. It’s unfortunate what these children are going through… If there is a silver lining, it’s Karma coming to Trump after he leaves office. Once Congress gets all Trumps financial records. All his fraudulent inflation of his assets to secure loans, all his deflation of his assets when it comes time to pay taxes… That’s a crime. I pray we play all these excerpts of Trump’s officials showing no mercy to the pain of these children. When the Trump family pleads in court, I’ll be grateful to relive these videos.

  42. "I notice none of the chicken factories nor their parent companies were named in any of the news coverage…Tyson Chicken wouldn't be one of the criminals would they?"

  43. I love our President, to all who hate him…you simply hate America and are most likely socialists.
    Your Democratic platform for 2020 is " I hate Trump, " and " Vote for me, you get stuff for free!"
    Insanity…meanwhile they want open borders so cartels can run in drugs, no voter ID so the illegals all come here and vote Democrat ( oh yah black ppl, they ARE replacing you with illegals, because black ppl are starting to wake up and realize that 40 years of Democrating voting gets them NOWHERE)
    The Dems have no polices that work, domestic and especially foreign…Biden wants to beg his way into the Iran Deal…the one that lets them make nukes!!
    You vote Dem, you are foolish.

  44. Illegal immigration has destroyed black communities, created more hatred against them, and corrupted their culture in America.

  45. When do the cries of the black communities in America that have been destroyed by illegal immigrants get to be heard?

  46. Ask the farmers who are losing millions of dollars,Now the kid's left behind are going to be adopted and after that the people who adopt them are going to get a Check for each child?? Now it would be Cheaper to let the parents Work!!Come on man,it would be a lot cheaper.

  47. Because them White folks are not going to Work in the Chicken Coup in Mississippi black's are not going to Work there either?? Black and White people knew about them job's black and White don't pick watermelon's and fruit,Veggies but they holl'a they Stealing our jobs?? (A big BS)

  48. Not 100 % immigrant is no good. we need to help those willing to work in this country, the truth is all of our race are from somewhere unless they are the original Indian.

  49. POOR HOMELESS AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE STREETS AND SIDEWALKS IN DEMOCRAT RUN DISTRICTS, THE DEMOCRATS AND FAKE LYING NEWS ARE MORE CONCERNED ABOUT I'LLEGALS THAN OUR OWN AMERICAN CITIZENS.POOR HOMELESS AMERICAN CITIZENS AND LYING ARI IS SAYING THIS JUST FOR PROPAGANDA AND THERE MAD BECAUSE NO MORE DEMOCRAT VOTER FRAUD USING I'LLEGALS.

  50. And the owner of the plant hires 700+ people illegally and he got a pass. And the irony of arresting people that are working.

  51. Fate whispered to President Trump…….. "You cannot withstand the storm"….

    President Trump whispered back…….."I AM the storm".

  52. come in the right way period! Because you can't go to Mexico and get in for free that's the truth, fix the problem now.

  53. And as the crops rot, Trump struts around thinking he's right. Wrong Mr. Trump, you painted yourself into a corner again.

  54. Trump and his minions in this administration are trying to take this country back when White Men thought they were “supreme.” Cuccinelli, the disgraced AG and horrible CNN legal commentator will have his day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *